How to Make a Unicorn Cake: Step-by-Step Guide

Unicorn cakes aren’t just adorable — they bring a whimsical charm to any party. This guide will take you through every detail to create a unicorn cake that’s bound to wow your guests. From the cake’s vibrant colors to the enchanting unicorn topper, we’ll explore the ingredients, decorating techniques, and unique finishing touches. So, roll up your sleeves, grab your baking essentials, and let’s make some magic!

Part 1: Introduction to Unicorn Cakes

Creating a unicorn cake can feel like crafting a fairytale. Unicorn cakes are popular for their dreamy design and vivid colors, perfect for birthdays and themed events. With a variety of decoration options, they let bakers unleash their creativity! But don’t worry if you’re a beginner; this guide will walk you through each step, making it easy for anyone to bring a touch of magic to the kitchen.

Part 2: Essential Tools and Ingredients for Unicorn Cake

Creating a beautiful unicorn cake requires a mix of specific tools and quality ingredients to ensure that each element — from the colorful layers to the intricate decorations — comes out perfectly. Below is a breakdown of the must-have tools and ingredients, along with a few pro tips for choosing the right supplies.

Baking Tools Needed

To bring your unicorn cake vision to life, you’ll want some basic baking tools:

  • Piping Bags and Nozzles: Essential for creating that fluffy, colorful unicorn mane. Having a few different nozzles can add variety to your mane’s texture and style.
  • Cake Turntable: Using a turntable allows smoother frosting and is especially helpful for beginners.
  • Spatula: A large spatula helps spread frosting evenly, while a small one is perfect for adding intricate details.
  • Food-Safe Brushes: These are great for dusting edible glitter or adding color accents.
  • Gel Food Coloring: Gel colors work best for vibrant shades without adding extra moisture, which can affect frosting consistency.

Ingredients for the Cake Base

For the cake itself, most bakers choose a light-colored cake — like vanilla or white cake — to let the colors pop. Here’s what you’ll need:

  • White Cake Mix or Homemade Cake Batter: Using a white cake as your base lets you add food coloring for a rainbow or tie-dye effect.
  • Egg Whites: This helps keep the cake light in color.
  • Milk or Water: Depending on your preference for a moist or light texture, use milk for richness or water for a fluffier cake.
  • Oil or Butter: Butter adds flavor, while oil makes a softer, moister cake.

Ingredients for the Frosting

A unicorn cake wouldn’t be complete without dreamy, pastel frosting! Buttercream is the go-to choice for its creamy texture and ease of coloring.

  • Butter: Gives a smooth, rich base for your frosting.
  • Powdered Sugar: Essential for sweetening and stabilizing the frosting.
  • Heavy Cream: Adds thickness and makes the frosting more spreadable.
  • Vanilla Extract: A small touch goes a long way for flavor.
  • Food Coloring: Gel-based colors allow vibrant hues in pinks, blues, purples, and more. Aim for a soft pastel palette that feels whimsical.

Optional Decorative Add-Ons

If you want to make your unicorn cake truly magical, consider these extras:

  • Edible Glitter: A dusting of glitter adds sparkle.
  • Sprinkles and Pearls: Fun options for adding color and texture.
  • Unicorn Cake Topper: This could be a fondant horn and ears you make yourself or store-bought items that add to the ease and elegance.
How to make a unicorn cake
How to make a unicorn cake

Part 3: Baking the Unicorn Cake Layers

Now that we have our tools and ingredients, it’s time to start baking! In this section, we’ll go step-by-step to create vibrant, perfectly baked layers that will be the foundation of your unicorn cake. For the best effect, consider layering multiple colors to achieve a beautiful rainbow cake when sliced.

Step 1: Prepping the Cake Pans

Before you start mixing, it’s important to prepare your cake pans to ensure easy removal and a smooth finish on each layer.

  1. Grease and Line the Pans: Grease each cake pan with a light layer of butter or nonstick spray, then place a round piece of parchment paper at the bottom for added protection.
  2. Preheat the Oven: Set your oven to 350°F (175°C) or the temperature recommended on your cake mix or recipe.

Step 2: Mixing the Cake Batter

To achieve a smooth and fluffy batter, follow these tips:

  1. Mix Ingredients Thoroughly: In a large bowl, mix your cake batter according to the recipe, ensuring it’s smooth and free of lumps. If you’re using a boxed white cake mix, add ingredients as instructed on the package, typically egg whites, oil, and water.
  2. Separate and Color the Batter: Divide the batter into several bowls, one for each color you plan to use. Add gel food coloring to each bowl and mix until the color is fully blended. Aim for colors like pink, blue, purple, and yellow to achieve that classic unicorn cake look.

Step 3: Baking the Layers

  1. Pour and Bake: Pour each colored batter into its prepared pan, creating even layers. Bake for 20-25 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.
  2. Cool the Cakes: Allow each layer to cool in the pan for about 10 minutes. Then, turn them out onto a wire rack to cool completely. This step is crucial because warm layers can cause the frosting to melt, so patience here will pay off!

Part 4: Assembling and Layering the Unicorn Cake

With your colorful cake layers ready, it’s time to bring everything together. This step will guide you through the assembly, layering, and frosting process to create a tall, beautifully stacked unicorn cake with evenly spread frosting and vivid layers.

Step 1: Leveling the Cake Layers

To ensure a sturdy, even cake, it’s important to trim the tops of each layer to create a flat surface.

  1. Use a Cake Leveler or Serrated Knife: Carefully slice off any domed tops from each layer. This will help prevent the cake from leaning or wobbling once assembled.
  2. Brush Off Crumbs: Lightly brush each layer with a pastry brush to remove excess crumbs, making it easier to apply frosting smoothly.

Step 2: Stacking the Layers

  1. Place the First Layer on Your Cake Board: Start with one of the most vibrant colors on the bottom to create a striking rainbow effect when sliced.
  2. Add a Thin Layer of Frosting: Using an offset spatula, spread a layer of buttercream frosting on top, extending it slightly over the edges. This will help hold the layers together and create a smooth foundation for the outer frosting.
  3. Repeat with Each Layer: Place the next layer on top and repeat the process, alternating colors for a beautiful visual effect. Apply a consistent amount of frosting between each layer to keep them balanced.

Step 3: Applying a Crumb Coat

To keep crumbs out of the final layer of frosting, it’s helpful to apply a crumb coat, which is a thin layer of frosting that seals in any loose crumbs.

  1. Spread a Thin Layer of Frosting Over the Entire Cake: Using an offset spatula, apply a thin coat of frosting around the sides and top of the cake. Don’t worry about it looking perfect; this layer is mainly to trap crumbs.
  2. Chill the Cake: Place the cake in the refrigerator for about 15-20 minutes to set the crumb coat. Chilling makes the frosting firm and helps the final layer adhere better.

Step 4: Adding the Final Frosting Layer

Once your crumb coat is set, it’s time to add the smooth outer layer.

  1. Apply a Generous Amount of Frosting: Using your offset spatula, spread a thick layer of frosting over the entire cake. Start with the top and then move to the sides, smoothing as you go.
  2. Smooth the Sides and Top: For a polished look, use a bench scraper or a cake smoother to go around the sides and top of the cake until the frosting is smooth and even.
How to make a unicorn cake
How to make a unicorn cake

Part 5: Decorating the Unicorn Cake – Adding the Mane, Horn, and Ears

With your cake layered and frosted, it’s time for the fun, decorative touches that make a unicorn cake truly magical! In this section, we’ll go over creating a colorful mane, attaching the unicorn horn and ears, and adding those little details that bring the unicorn theme to life.

Step 1: Creating the Unicorn Mane with Buttercream

The mane is one of the defining features of a unicorn cake, often designed with swirls of vibrant colors that cascade down one side of the cake.

  1. Prepare Multiple Colors of Frosting: Divide your buttercream into small bowls and add gel food coloring to create a pastel color palette, including pink, purple, blue, and yellow.
  2. Fill the Piping Bags: Use different piping bags for each color, fitting them with star or open star tips to create textured swirls for the mane.
  3. Pipe the Mane: Starting from the top center of the cake, pipe swirls and rosettes along one side, allowing the mane to flow down. Alternate colors to add depth and vibrancy.

Step 2: Adding the Unicorn Horn and Ears

The unicorn’s horn and ears can be made from fondant, which holds its shape well and adds a professional touch to the cake.

  1. Creating the Horn: Roll a piece of fondant into a cone shape, tapering it at the top. For a classic spiral look, you can twist it slightly, then dust it with edible gold dust for that magical sparkle.
  2. Making the Ears: Shape two small triangles from fondant for the ears, adding a little pink color in the center of each for a realistic touch.
  3. Attach the Horn and Ears: Insert a toothpick or skewer at the bottom of the horn and carefully press it into the top center of the cake. Position the ears slightly behind the horn, angled outward for a cute effect.

Step 3: Adding Finishing Touches

  1. Sprinkles and Pearls: Scatter a few edible pearls or sprinkles around the mane to add texture and visual appeal.
  2. Edible Glitter: Lightly dust the mane and horn with edible glitter to make the cake shine.
  3. Eyes and Additional Details: Use a black food coloring pen or small dabs of frosting to create closed eyes with lashes, adding a playful and magical look.

Part 6: Creative Variations and Additional Unicorn Cake Ideas

Once you’ve mastered the basic unicorn cake, you can explore various creative twists to customize it for any occasion. In this section, we’ll cover different ways to make your cake even more unique, from changing the color palette to adding extra decorations. These ideas can transform your unicorn cake into a truly personalized work of art.

  • Idea 1: Experiment with Color Themes
  1. Pastel Rainbow: Stick with softer, pastel colors for a delicate, dreamy unicorn look that’s perfect for younger children’s birthday parties.
  2. Bold and Bright: Use more intense colors like hot pink, electric blue, and neon yellow for a striking, eye-catching unicorn mane.
  3. Metallic Accents: Add metallic edible paint or dust on the horn, mane, and ears for a magical shimmer. Metallics like gold, silver, and rose gold can make the cake look elegant and trendy.
  • Idea 2: Adding Extra Decorations
  1. Flowers and Edible Gems: Enhance the mane with edible flowers, sugar gems, or pearls for added detail and texture.
  2. Candy Accents: Add colorful candies or small marshmallows around the base or mane, creating a whimsical effect kids will love.
  3. Rainbow Layers Inside: For an extra surprise, make the inside of the cake rainbow-colored by adding multiple colors to the batter. Each slice will reveal vibrant layers, adding to the unicorn magic.
  • Idea 3: Incorporate Themes and Personalization
  1. Seasonal Variations: Make a holiday-themed unicorn cake by using seasonally inspired colors. For example, reds, greens, and golds work beautifully for a festive unicorn cake around Christmas.
  2. Name or Message: Add a personalized touch by writing the birthday child’s name or a fun message on the cake board or directly on the cake with edible ink or frosting.

Part 7: Storing and Serving the Unicorn Cake

With your beautiful unicorn cake complete, let’s go over the best ways to store it, ensuring it remains fresh and picture-perfect for your celebration. We’ll also look at some presentation tips to make serving this masterpiece a magical experience.

Storing the Unicorn Cake

  1. Short-Term Storage: If you’re planning to serve the cake within a few hours, simply keep it covered at room temperature in a cool area. A cake dome or plastic wrap can help protect it from dust and keep it moist.
  2. Refrigerating the Cake: For storage beyond a few hours, place the cake in the refrigerator. Cover it with plastic wrap or place it in an airtight container to prevent the buttercream from drying out or absorbing odors. Let it sit at room temperature for about 30 minutes before serving to allow the frosting to soften.
  3. Freezing for Future Use: You can also freeze the cake if you’re making it ahead of time. Freeze it uncovered for an hour to firm up the frosting, then wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and aluminum foil. When you’re ready to serve, let it thaw in the refrigerator overnight, then bring it to room temperature before the event.

Serving the Unicorn Cake

  1. Presentation Tips: Place the cake on a stand that complements its colors, like a pastel or metallic cake stand. For added flair, sprinkle edible glitter or stars around the base.
  2. Slicing for a Show-Stopping Reveal: Use a sharp, warm knife to slice through the cake layers, revealing the vibrant colors within. Wipe the knife between cuts for clean, precise slices.
  3. Serving Size Suggestions: Unicorn cakes are usually rich, so small, delicate slices are ideal. For parties, you may want to pre-slice pieces to make serving easier.
How to make a unicorn cake
How to make a unicorn cake

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is a unicorn cake made of?

A unicorn cake is typically made with layers of colorful sponge cake, which is often frosted with buttercream or fondant. The cake is decorated to resemble a unicorn, featuring a unicorn horn (usually made from fondant), ears, and a vibrant, cascading mane of swirled colored frosting. The inside of the cake can also be made in rainbow layers for an added surprise when the cake is cut.

2. How do you make a unicorn cake at home?

Making a unicorn cake involves several key steps:

  • Bake the cake: Use your favorite cake recipe and separate the batter into multiple bowls to add food coloring for a rainbow effect.
  • Layer the cake: Once the cakes are baked and cooled, level and stack the layers, adding buttercream frosting between each layer.
  • Crumb coat: Apply a thin coat of frosting to seal in the crumbs, then refrigerate for a smoother final layer.
  • Decorate: Pipe the mane using different colored buttercream, then add a fondant horn and ears. Finish with edible glitter or pearls for a magical touch.

3. What colors are best for a unicorn cake?

The best colors for a unicorn cake are soft pastels or vibrant, bold colors that resemble a rainbow. Commonly used colors include pink, purple, blue, yellow, and green. Pastel shades create a dreamy effect, while brighter tones can make the cake pop for a fun celebration. You can also use metallic colors like gold or silver for a magical shine on the horn and details.

4. Can I make a unicorn cake without fondant?

Yes, you can make a unicorn cake without fondant by using only buttercream for decorations. The unicorn horn can be made from buttercream piped into a cone shape, or you can use other edible materials, such as chocolate, for the horn. This approach is simpler and may be more suitable for beginners.

5. How far in advance can I make a unicorn cake?

You can make a unicorn cake a day or two in advance. If you need to make it earlier, it’s best to freeze the layers and assemble the cake on the day before serving. For storage, wrap the cake tightly in plastic wrap and keep it in the fridge to maintain freshness. Decorate the cake no more than a day in advance to preserve the look and texture of the decorations.

6. Can I make a unicorn cake gluten-free?

Absolutely! You can make a gluten-free unicorn cake by substituting regular flour with a gluten-free flour blend. Just ensure the rest of your ingredients, such as baking powder and butter, are also gluten-free. There are plenty of gluten-free cake recipes available that can easily be adapted for the unicorn theme.

Conclusion: Creating Your Magical Unicorn Cake

Making a unicorn cake is a delightful and creative process that can transform an ordinary celebration into something truly magical. Whether you’re crafting a simple cake with a swirled pastel mane or adding more intricate details like metallic accents and colorful candies, this fun project allows you to bring your imagination to life. From selecting the right cake flavors to perfecting the decorations, each step is a chance to add your personal touch and make the cake uniquely yours.

As you’ve learned, the process doesn’t need to be daunting. With the right techniques, you can create a stunning unicorn cake that will wow guests and leave them in awe. Whether you’re baking for a birthday, a themed party, or just for fun, your unicorn cake will surely be the star of the show.

Now that you have all the tips and tricks, it’s time to get baking! Gather your ingredients, choose your colors, and let your creativity flow. Don’t forget to take plenty of photos of your masterpiece before it’s devoured — after all, you’ve created a piece of edible art.

Enjoy the process and the smiles that come with serving such a whimsical treat. Your unicorn cake will be remembered long after the candles are blown out.

Leave a Comment